Tim Dillon's Brutally Honest Take on Why Austin Fails as a Comedy Hub

Tim Dillon opens with a blunt dismissal of Austin as a city, emphasizing that it simply cannot be compared to comedy hubs like New York or Los Angeles. He states:

"You cannot compare it... Sorry to New York or Los Angeles." 0

He paints Austin as a small, unpleasant place with a dangerous environment, aggressive homelessness, and a lack of greenery. His description is vivid and unflattering:

"The city of Austin Texas... is dangerous. The homeless there are more aggressive than I've ever seen them in New York... It's small. It's brown. There's no grass. It turns brown for four months out of the year. It's over 100°. The lake is vomit colored. And there are brain eating amebas that can swim up your nose and kill you within 48 hours." 0:40

Key points:

• Austin is small and lacks natural beauty.
• The homeless population is aggressive, worse than in New York.
• Environmental hazards like brain-eating amebas exist.
• The city’s climate is harsh and unappealing for much of the year.
• Tim’s perspective is grounded in his identity as a New York comedian, skeptical of Austin’s hype.

Tim’s skepticism extends to the comedy scene itself, which he and Mark Normand critique as overhyped and self-congratulatory. Mark points out the irony of a city needing to advertise itself as the “next big thing”:

"If you have to advertise a city as the next big thing then it's probably not that." 2:55

Mark compares this to people who constantly post wedding photos, implying that constant self-promotion signals insecurity. Tim and Mark agree that New York’s comedy scene is authentic because everyone complains about it, but they love it deeply:

"The great thing about New York everyone shits on it... Even the people that love it go you have no idea how much it sucks... That's cuz we love it." 3:05

Key points:

• Austin comedy scene is seen as cringe and self-glorifying.
• The need for constant promotion suggests a lack of genuine status.
• New York’s comedy scene is gritty and loved despite its flaws.
• Tim and Mark value authenticity over manufactured hype.

Tim highlights the bizarre political mix in Austin, describing it as a melting pot of extremes:

"It's the worst of the right and the worst of the left... everyone's either like a proud boy who's ready to get in a brawl or it's like a non-binary blue-haired dreadlock gremlin." 3:54

He and Mark joke about the lack of “normal” people, suggesting the city is dominated by college kids and tourists caught in a culture war:

"Is there any normal human? No, people are like college kids or tourists." 4:06

Key points:

• Austin attracts extreme political factions, creating tension.
• The city lacks a moderate or “normal” demographic.
• This polarization contributes to a chaotic social environment.

Tim, Mark, and Sam Morril agree that New York and Los Angeles will always be better for comedy than Austin. This is notable because many in the Joe Rogan sphere criticize LA, but these comedians defend it:

"I despise the government there. I despise their smugness... But even though Los Angeles has its drawbacks... I still enjoy it more than Austin." 4:48

They compare the two cities metaphorically:

"New York is like a family that's constantly yelling at each other... LA is a family that never speaks." 5:23

This contrast highlights different social dynamics but both cities have strong comedy communities.

Key points:

• LA and New York have established, vibrant comedy scenes.
• Despite flaws, LA is preferred over Austin by these comedians.
• The social atmosphere in NY is chaotic but familial; LA is quieter but still connected.
• The Rogan-driven narrative of LA’s collapse is challenged here.

Tim’s most compelling argument is economic: Austin lacks the massive wealth and infrastructure that sustain California’s entertainment industry. He explains:

"Every time Joe Rogan said LA was on the brink of disaster nothing ever really happened... California runs off this really consolidated huge bundle of money from tech companies in Northern California." 6:26

He points out the importance of Stanford and the Bay Area as a talent and money hub, something Austin cannot replicate:

"You can't recruit out of Rice University in Houston... You need Stanford." 7:09

Tim stresses that cultural and economic ecosystems develop over long periods and cannot be transplanted overnight:

"You can't just make a thing what you want it to be in a week... Areas have cultures that develop for very long periods of time." 7:33

Key points:

• California’s tech wealth underpins LA’s entertainment industry.
• Austin lacks comparable universities and tech ecosystems.
• Cultural hubs like Hollywood and Silicon Valley are irreplaceable.
• Attempts to replicate these ecosystems elsewhere are unlikely to succeed quickly.

The video closes with a critical look at recent moves by comedians like Brian Callen and Brendan Schaub to Austin. While Callen might benefit from Rogan’s support, Schaub is portrayed as relying on a fading “right-wing trucker bro” persona:

"Sha... is just in for a rude awakening... his merch line has symbols eerily similar to some used by German guys during World War II." 9:09

The Mothership’s flagship show Kill Tony is described as declining, signaling the potential burnout of Austin’s comedy scene:

"The only thing the Mothership's got going for it right now is Kill Tony... and that show is dying out too." 9:44

The creator predicts a slow, cringe-worthy decline for Austin as a comedy hub.

Key points:

• Some comedians are moving to Austin, but not all with promising prospects.
• The Mothership and its shows are losing relevance.
• Austin is becoming a place where less successful comedians go.
• The scene’s peak may already be behind it.

---

This breakdown captures Tim Dillon’s candid and often harsh critique of Austin as a city and comedy hub, contrasting it with the established scenes of New York and LA. His points about environment, culture, politics, and economics provide a grounded explanation for why Austin is unlikely to replace these cities despite the hype fueled by Joe Rogan and others. The video also touches on the personal and professional consequences for comedians who buy into the Austin migration trend.